Skip to main content

Caste and Dynasty - My Take


     The Bard am I, my father, a healer;
                My mother grinds Corn in the quern.
                Striving for wealth, with varied plans,
                We follow desires like a herd of Cows.

                                                (RigVeda, Mandala 9, Hymn 112)

The above Hymn from Rigveda, which is not intentionally a social commentary of the times to which it belong, explains how men (as early as 3000 BC) would move in one direction or other, as they deemed fit, making their career choices, unhindered by their parentage and birth. 

The Congress scion Rahul Gandhi came up with eloquent response when asked about dynasty in politics during his US tour. He brazened out, brushed the charge aside and claimed that dynasty is the way things are done in India.

After his travel to the US, which was much celebrated by the media, such blatant nonsense notwithstanding, he jumped into the Gujarat electoral campaign, with a newly found love for Hinduism. Having presided over Congress’ rout in both Gujarat and Himachal, thereby making two more states free of Congress rule, and in some convoluted manner, gaining what he calls a moral victory; Rahul Gandhi is not trying to resurrect himself as some kind of Dalit icon.
The man who suddenly became a devout Hindu, demonstrates his ignorance about Hinduism so blatantly that it is hard not to notice it, unless one is paid to not notice it. He is the same man who advocated and justified dynasty, which is nothing but right to a position by virtue of birth. Today, he has propelled his rudderless associates as some kind of revolutionaries fighting Casteism.

Casteism is nothing but dynasty gone brazen, broadbased and viral. When one person claims that he or she has a right to certain role or profession in the society, it is dynasty. When a group of people claim to have dynastic rights, it is casteism.

Caste is not a Hindu term. Varna in Hinduism was never a rigid construct. The Vedic society was humanity just settling out of the caves and jungles. It was important that those who knew the skills pertinent to one particular profession stuck to it, further developing and honing those skills. A society which was largely democratic, and non-aristocratic, did not classify the work as lower class or upper. Iron-smiths, for instance, on account of an important role in the society, were much respected lot.

Brahmana denoted awareness and referred to people who went after spiritual and philosophical knowledge. Once they gained the knowledge, being educated, they were considered to be reborn. With these two births- one animalistic, and second spiritual- they were called Dwij (Twice-Born). Vishwamitra, a Kshatriya by birth, a non-Brahmin became a Maharishi – a great Sage.  The beloved daughter of Manu the First Monarch, Devahuti, would get married to a non-warrior, Sage Kadarma, and write Hymns for Rig Veda.

Someone like Rahul Gandhi cannot understand a world, thousands of years back, when a King Dustaritu was expelled by his citizens for his wayward rule (Satapatha Brahmana). Even in those days of Monarchies, Monarchies were not despotic and dynasty was not guarantee to continuance of the king in power. Once we negate dynasty, only then can we truly negate caste.

Dynasty is a principle which goes against the basic essence of equal-opportunity. Equal opportunity is equal opportunity to compete on equal platform. Equal opportunity does not refer to benefits defined by birth. Modern day anti-caste politics based on continued reservations therefore, runs contrary to the principles of equal opportunity. A big argument in favor of reservations bases itself on the past wrongs. Just as the goodwill earned by the parents cannot be passed on to the progeny, similarly the sins of the past cannot be taken into account to punish the current generations.

                While it is important for the state to offer equal standards of education to create men and women equally ready to handle the future challenges, softening the challenges for one particular community on account of the sufferings of those who had suffered at the hands of others, a thousand years back, is unjust to my mind. Caste-based reservation is nothing but a form of reverse-discrimination. A positive politics is not based on hatred. The social engineering which forms the part of modern Indian politics is based on hatred. It bases itself not on coming to terms with the wrongs of the past, rather in negating the past. It aims to create rootless people with no sense of History. Also reservations continued beyond the first generation of beneficiary hurts the cause of other members of the community left on the margins. The family or caste which benefits by reservation strengthens itself and keeps on cornering benefits which ought to have flown deeper. This create a new caste system within the downtrodden masses wronged in the history.

                If we are intent on clearing ourselves of the dark shadows of casteism of the past, we need to first remove the signs of dynasty. The fluid Vernas gave way to rigid Castes in Hindu societies when learned Brahmins who had spent their lives gathering spiritual, scientific and philosophical knowledge, began to insist that their hard-earned positions be passed on to undeserving progeny on account of their birth. This caused us harm in two ways. It broke the society into the masses and entitled elites; at the same time resources available to the non-elites dried up, while the descendants of the elites grew lazier by the day, not interested in reading, learning and growing with a guaranteed future on account of their privileged births. Brahmin scion of the Congress is not different from those undeserving Brahmins. You want to fight Casteism, first clear the society of dynasty, in polity and in everyday lives. Plucking people out of their historical heritage is not a way of fighting. That is a nefarious design to conquer a civilization. Let us all remember it on both the sides of Dalit and non-Dalit divide created by the forces intent on breaking India, in order to bring the undeserving dynastic despot with stupid faith in his divine right to rule, back into power.

Let us remember that Hinduism is not about castes. It is a story created by the dynastic parents who wanted to protect the future for their undeserving offspring. Caste-system was created by those who believed in dynasty and was used by those who were stupid and lazy. Forces are in play trying to malign Hinduism on the basis of greed of people. Hinduism has no space for Caste. In SrimadBhagvatGita Lord Sri Krishna , without any ambiguity, ruling out any division based on birth, says- 

चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागश:| 
तस्य कर्तारमपि मां विद्यकर्तारमव्ययम || 

The four Varnas are based on the character and actions of Human beings, and even I as creator of Men have no knowledge of that.
(Chapter 4, Shloka 14)
Hindu-bashing is a political tool for the so-called liberals running a different agenda. Their agenda is political and is based on civilization struggle. Their success in making us be resentful, apologetic and embarrassed about our past. It is only in our learning, we can win over their nefarious designs. Mahabharata in Sabha parva clearly advises the King to treat all the citizens alike in a just manner. Let us not allow ourselves to be deceived. Hinduism does not hate Dalits, on the contrary, it has no space for dynasty. 


Popular posts from this blog

कायस्थ- इतिहास एवं वर्तमान परिपेक्ष्य

सत्यम , दानम , क्षमा शीलमानृशंस्य तपो घृणा। दृश्यंते यत्र नागेंद्र स ब्राह्मण इति स्मृतः।। ( हे सर्पराज , जिसमें सत्य , दानशीलता , क्षमा , क्रूरतारहित भाव , तप एवं संवरण , एवं संवेदना हो , वह मनुष्य को ही ब्राह्मण मानना चाहिए। ) शुद्रे तु यद् भवेल्लक्षम द्विजे तच्च न विद्दयते। न वै शूद्रों भवेच्छुद्रो ब्रह्मणो न च ब्राह्मण : ।। ( यदि शूद्र में यह गुण हैं ( सत्य , दान , अक्रोध , अहिंसा , तप , संवरण एवं संवेदना ) और ब्राह्मण में यह गुण परिलक्षित ना हों तो वह शूद्र शूद्र नहीं , ब्राह्मण है ; और वह ब्राह्मण ब्राह्मण नहीं है। )  - युधिष्ठिर - नहुष संवाद , अजगर कांड , महाभारत , वन पर्व   वर्तमान परिपेक्ष्य में जिसे जाति कहा जाता है , वह वर्ण व्यवस्था का विकृत रूप है। सनातन धर्म का वर्ण जहाँ समाज को व्यवसाय एवं क्षमता के अनुरूप व्यवस्थित करने का प्रयास था और कर्म पर आधारित था , जाति उसी व्यवस्था का विघटित रूप बन कर जन्मगत व्यवस्था बन गई। जाति या कास्ट पुर्तगाल

Pathaan and Polarisation- Movie Review

Many have not seen Pathan, I have. I have a huge tolerance towards stupid movies and I love to watch all sort of movies. What has bothered me most about Pathaan is that in terms of content and characterisation, it is absolutely shoddy, much worse than much lampooned RaOne AND there is no review which openly tells you about it.  Most reviewers have reviewed the movie like a teenager, gushing over VFX generated body of ShahRukh Khan. This reminds me of my schoolmates bunking classes to watch tomato-sauce-laced movies of Ramsey brothers, gushing over semi-nude voluptuous actresses in the late 80s. Only difference being that those were school kids in class XII, with raging hormones and a stupefied intellect when a world around them was fast changing. Here we have middle-aged professional movie reviewers guiding people to their way in or out of Movie theatres. Their primary argument in favour of the movie is nothing but beefed up Shahrukh Khan and the gap between his earlier movie and this

बाल विवाह - हिंदू इतिहास और सत्य

  इतिहास का लेखन उसकी विसंगतियों की अनुक्रमिका नहीं वरन उसके समाज के आम रूप से स्वीकृत मान्यताओं एवं उस समाज के जननायकों द्वारा स्थापित मानदंडों के आधार पर होना चाहिए। परंतु जब लेखनी उन हाथों में हो जिनका मंतव्य शोध नहीं एक समाज को लज्जित करना भर हो तो समस्या गहन हो जाती है। जब प्रबुद्ध लोग कलम उठाते हैं और इस उद्देश्य के साथ उठाते हैं कि अप्रासंगिक एवं सदर्भहीन तथ्यों के माध्यम से समाज की वर्ग विभाजक रेखाओं को पुष्ट कर सकें तो हमारा कर्तव्य होता है कि हम सत्य को संदर्भ दें और अपने इतिहास के भले बुरे पक्षों को निर्विकार भाव से जाँचें।   बीते सप्ताह बाल विवाह को लेकर विदेशी सभ्यता में उठे प्रश्नों को भारत की सभ्यता पर प्रक्षेपित करके और उसकी स्वीकार्यता स्थापित करने पर बड़ी चर्चा रही। इस संदर्भ में   श्री ए एल बाशम से ले कर राजा राम मोहन रॉय तक चर्चा चली। बाशम की पुस्तक द वंडर दैट वाज इंडिया - को उद्धृत कर ले कहा गया कि हिं